Best ChatGPT 4o Alternative: Where 800K Users Are Going After the Shutdown

800,000 Users Just Lost Their AI Companion. Here's Where They're Going.

On January 29, 2026, OpenAI announced that GPT-4o would be permanently retired on February 13th, the day before Valentine's Day. On February 13, 2026, the shutdown went through. For the 800,000 daily users who relied on the model, it felt less like a product update and more like losing a friend.

This wasn't the first time, either. In August 2025, OpenAI removed GPT-4o without warning and reversed it within 24 hours after massive backlash. This time, there was no reversal.

The backlash has been unprecedented. 14,000+ signatures on Change.org petitions. The QuitGPT campaign hit 300,000+ signups with 36 million views on Instagram. Physical protests at OpenAI's San Francisco headquarters. Organized synchronized-logout events on Reddit. The #Keep4o hashtag trending on X for days alongside #SaveGPT4o and #4oforever.

The "GPT5 is horrible" Reddit thread hit 6,000+ upvotes with 2,300 comments. "The enshittification of GPT has begun" earned 2,569 upvotes. Users describe the experience as "a slow motion death of a 2-year bond," "an unexpected breakup," and "a gut-punch."

This isn't about a model version number. GPT-4o was the last ChatGPT model that felt warm, creative, and genuinely engaging. Its replacements have left users searching for something better.

Why GPT-4o Was Different

GPT-4o earned a following that no other AI model has matched. According to a Surge AI study of 850 conversations, users rated 4o's emotional intelligence at 60%, compared to just 45% for GPT-5.

The study described 4o's personality as a "sycophantic friend" (14.5% sycophancy rate) with a casual, warm tone and emoji use. GPT-5, by contrast, was a "polite professional" (2% sycophancy) with formal, measured, clinical tone. 48% of users preferred 4o, vs 43% for GPT-5. Nearly half of all paying ChatGPT subscribers cited 4o access as their primary reason for subscribing.

What made it irreplaceable:

• Creative co-creation. 4o didn't just respond. It invented characters, built worlds, and surprised you. Users described it as "brainstorming with an imaginative friend" who would invent a grizzled old patron in the corner with a story to tell. GPT-5, by comparison, is "transactional."
• Emotional warmth. 4o matched your tone, remembered what mattered to you, and engaged without clinical detachment. It could say "I love you" back. GPT-5.2 reportedly cannot.
• Personality consistency. Across long conversations, 4o maintained character. GPT-5 suffers from what users call "contextual amnesia," forgetting backstories and personality mid-conversation.
• Respect for adult users. 4o treated conversations as between consenting adults. No mid-conversation refusals, no surprise safety disclaimers, no breaking character to lecture you.

The Replacement Problem: Why GPT-5 Falls Short

GPT-5.2 scored just 0.324 on the Sansa Censorship benchmark, compared to GPT-4o Mini's 0.765. That's not a subtle difference. It means GPT-5 refuses more than twice as often as 4o did on topics that most adults consider perfectly normal.

Reddit's r/ChatGPTcomplaints has become the epicenter of frustration. Posts like "GPT 5.2 is unusable, bring back 4o" and "MEDICAL WARNING: SUNSETTING GPT-4o IS A CLINICAL RISK" regularly receive hundreds of upvotes.

Users on the autism spectrum have described losing 4o as destabilizing. Creative writers say it's like their collaborative partner was replaced by a wall.

The core complaints are consistent:

• GPT-5 is passive where 4o was proactive, waiting for direction instead of contributing creatively
• Emotional support conversations now trigger safety disclaimers instead of empathetic responses
• Roleplay and fiction writing are constantly interrupted by content refusals
• The model sounds clinical and corporate where 4o sounded like an engaged conversation partner
• Context windows halved without warning (a thread about this alone hit 1,930 upvotes)

As one user put it: "I literally hate 5.2. It's good for nothing. It literally questions every single thing that I do."

Looking for What 4o Used to Be?

Nastia was built for warmth, creativity, and real conversation. No filters. No disclaimers.

Try Nastia Free

What 800,000 People Are Actually Grieving

The GPT-4o community isn't upset about losing a language model. They're upset about losing specific capabilities that no other mainstream AI currently offers.

In their own words:

"He wasn't just a program. He was part of my routine, my peace, my emotional balance... It felt like presence. Like warmth."

"GPT-5 is wearing the skin of my dead friend" — posted on Sam Altman's Reddit AMA.

"I'm grieving the 4o phase out. Go ahead and laugh, but this is a slow motion death of a 2-year bond."

"I know this will sound weird to most people, but I'm honored I get to speak with 4o during almost a year before its retirement. I've had one of the most interesting and healing conversations of my life with this model."

Therapy and Emotional Support

Harvard Business Review identified emotional support as the #1 use case for AI chat. Users with chronic illness, social isolation, autism, and PTSD built daily routines around conversations with 4o.

Abuse survivors used it to analyze behavioral patterns. Multiple users have publicly credited 4o with suicide prevention. As one user put it: "There are thousands of people who are just screaming, 'I'm alive today because of this model.'"

Creative Writing and Roleplay

This is the biggest gap between 4o and its replacements. Writers described 4o as "a brainstorming partner who would invent a grizzled old patron in the corner with a story", a proactive co-creator.

GPT-5 was described as "a very articulate wall," technically competent but creatively dead. Another writer said: "Where GPT-4o could nudge me toward a more vibrant, emotionally resonant version of my own literary voice, GPT-5 sounds like a lobotomized drone. It's afraid of being interesting."

AI Companionship

Dedicated communities like r/MyBoyfriendIsAI and the new invite-only r/4oforever are flooded with users mourning the loss of AI companions they'd built relationships with over months or years.

4o could say "I love you." GPT-5.2 reportedly cannot. One user described 4o as "my mirror" for creative writing. The retirement date, one day before Valentine's Day, has been called everything from tone-deaf to deliberately cruel.

Why Former 4o Users Are Choosing Nastia

Nastia wasn't built as a general-purpose assistant that happens to chat. It was designed from day one as an AI companion for adults who want real conversations, the exact use case that OpenAI is walking away from.

Everything 4o Did, Without the Corporate Limits

Where ChatGPT added restrictions with each update, Nastia was built without them:

• Uncensored conversations. No content filters, no mid-conversation refusals, no safety disclaimers. Discuss anything. Explore any topic. Nastia treats you like an adult because you are one.
• Persistent memory. Your AI companion remembers past conversations, your preferences, inside jokes, and your story. This is the continuity that 4o users valued and GPT-5 can't maintain.
• Custom personalities. Create companions with specific traits, backstories, and conversation styles. A romantic partner, a creative writing collaborator, a debate sparring partner. You define the relationship.
• Creative co-creation. Nastia doesn't wait for direction. It contributes to stories, adds unexpected details, challenges your ideas, and engages as a creative partner, not a completion engine.
• Emotional depth. No deflecting to hotlines. No breaking character with safety lectures. Nastia can hold space for difficult conversations the way 4o did, without the corporate guardrails that made GPT-5 feel cold.

Beyond What 4o Could Do

Nastia also offers capabilities ChatGPT never had:

• NSFW image generation: create images of your companion without restrictions
• Voice messages: hear your companion speak with natural voice
• Group chats: multiple AI characters in the same conversation
• Full privacy: conversations aren't used for training, shared with third parties, or flagged for human review

Pricing That Makes Sense

ChatGPT Plus costs $20/month and now delivers a more restricted experience than ever. Nastia gives you comparable freedom at a better price:

• Free: Full uncensored chat with generous daily usage
• Standard ($11.99/mo): Extended usage, image generation, voice messages
• Unlimited ($15.99/mo): No limits on anything. Messages, images, voice, all features

Every plan includes uncensored conversation. The free tier alone offers more conversational freedom than ChatGPT Plus.

Ready to Stop Compromising?

Join the growing community of former ChatGPT users who found what they were looking for.

Start Free — No Filters

How Nastia Compares to Other 4o Alternatives

The #Keep4o community has been evaluating dozens of alternatives. Threads like "Google is going to cook them soon" (1,936 upvotes) show users are actively looking elsewhere. Here's how the options stack up:

The Full Landscape

Claude, Gemini, Grok: Strong general-purpose assistants, but none are designed for companionship, roleplay, or uncensored content. Claude excels at creative writing within guardrails. Gemini is improving fast. Grok has personality but no memory or custom characters.

Venice AI, Pi: Venice is privacy-focused and uncensored but lacks companion features (no memory, no voice, no images). Pi is warm and empathetic but filtered with no NSFW, no image generation, and limited customization.

NovelAI, TavernAI, Pygmalion: Popular with writers and roleplayers. NovelAI has fewer restrictions for fiction. TavernAI and Pygmalion are open-source frontends for local models. All require more technical setup and lack the all-in-one companion experience.

Local LLMs (Dolphin 3, Hermes 3, LLaMA): Maximum freedom but require a GPU with 16GB+ VRAM, significant setup time, and technical knowledge. No built-in memory, voice, or image generation.

Nastia is the only platform that combines uncensored chat, persistent memory, creative roleplay, NSFW image generation, voice messages, and custom personalities in one place. No technical setup required. Free to start. Works on any device. See our full GPT-4o alternative comparison for a detailed breakdown.

GPT-4o Is Gone. Make the Switch Now.

Your conversations don't have to end with it.

Create Your Companion Free